MilkShake Factory Just Brought Its Shakes to Middletown, Its First Shop in Monmouth County

Monmouth County has its first MilkShake Factory. The Pittsburgh born dessert chain held the grand opening celebration for its fifth New Jersey location on Saturday, November 14, at 1377 Route 35 in Middletown Plaza, the shopping center anchored by Trader Joe's.

The shop has actually been serving since mid October, and Saturday was the party: buy one get one free shakes, sundaes and molten cups from noon to 4 PM, free T-shirts for the first 100 guests, a gift basket for the first guest in line, and free chocolate sampling through the afternoon.

The Middletown shop is run by John Walsh and his wife, Andrea Walsh. It is a compact store, 1,377 square feet, a funny match for its 1377 Route 35 address, set in the plaza alongside Petco and RetroFitness.

If you only know the name, here is the backstory: MilkShake Factory began in 1914 in Pittsburgh as a chocolate company and soda fountain founded by Charlie and Orania Sarandou, who immigrated from Greece. More than a century later it is still built on the same two things, handspun milkshakes and small batch premium chocolates, with house made ice cream in between.

The menu runs from classic shakes and sundaes to molten cups and chocolate barks, and delivery through DoorDash started November 9. Winter is already planned: a peppermint fudge brownie shake, regular and peppermint hot chocolate, and seasonal chocolate barks.

This is the chain's fifth shop in New Jersey, following the Ridgewood location KezusGuides covered earlier this fall, and its first at the Shore. Dessert chains keep choosing Route 35 corridors for a reason, and Middletown just got a strong one.

MilkShake Factory, 1377 Route 35, Middletown Plaza, Middletown. Open daily, noon to 10 PM.

KEEP READING: More New Jersey food news and guides on KezusGuides.

Previous
Previous

A Fairfield Italian Restaurant Just Turned Into Whoville for the Holidays

Next
Next

Hobby’s Deli in Newark Just Put a Devils Burger and a Hellebuyck Lava Cake on the Menu